Newschevron_rightBlog: Is a contractual relationship required for econ…


Blog: Is a contractual relationship required for economic dependence? The Belgian Court of Cassation says no.

20 november 2026
Dispute resolution Case highlight Publication

A company may be economically dependent on another company even in the absence of a contractual relationship between them.

In a judgment of 20 February 2025, the Belgian Court of Cassation clarified an important aspect of the Belgian prohibition of the abuse of economic dependence and confirmed that a contractual link is not a prerequisite for economic dependence.

The judgment provides valuable guidance on the scope of Article IV.2/1 of the Belgian Code of Economic Law (CEL), a provision that has attracted considerable attention since its introduction into Belgian competition law.

What is economic dependence?

Article IV.2/1 CEL prohibits the abuse of a position of economic dependence where competition on the Belgian market, or a substantial part of it, may be affected.

The concept of economic dependence was introduced to address situations where a company may not hold a dominant position on the market, yet still possesses significant bargaining power vis-à-vis a specific business partner.

Under the Code of Economic Law, economic dependence exists when an undertaking lacks a reasonably equivalent alternative available within a reasonable time, under reasonable conditions and at reasonable cost.

The question before the Court

Since the introduction of Article IV.2/1 CEL, legal practitioners have debated whether economic dependence can only exist where the parties concerned are in a contractual relationship.

Some argued that such a contractual relationship was an implicit requirement. Others maintained that neither the wording of the law nor its legislative history imposed such a condition.

The Court of Cassation has now settled that debate.

The Court's judgment

According to the Court, neither the text of the legislation nor the preparatory parliamentary works support the conclusion that a contractual relationship is required for the existence of economic dependence.

As a result, a company may invoke the protection offered by Article IV.2/1 CEL even where no contract exists between the parties.

The judgment therefore confirms that the scope of the economic dependence regime is not limited to traditional supplier-customer relationships.

Why does this matter?

The ruling potentially broadens the practical reach of Article IV.2/1 CEL.

Companies seeking to rely on the prohibition of abuse of economic dependence can no longer be confronted with the argument that their claim automatically fails because no contractual relationship exists.

That said, a claimant must still demonstrate:

  • the existence of economic dependence (where the presence or absence of a contractual relationship may still be factually relevant);

  • abusive conduct; and

  • a potential impact on competition on the Belgian market or a substantial part thereof.

A broader competition law debate

The judgment answers one important question, but it also raises another.

If economic dependence may exist without a contractual relationship, where should the boundaries between the prohibition of abuse of economic dependence and the traditional prohibition of abuse of dominance be drawn?

This issue is explored by our counsel Benjamin Magnus in his recent contribution to Rechtskundig Weekblad, which analyses both the Court's reasoning and the wider implications of the judgment for Belgian competition law.

Key Takeaways

  • A contractual relationship is not required for the application of Article IV.2/1 CEL.

  • Economic dependence may exist even in the absence of a direct contractual link between the parties.

  • The judgment provides further guidance on the scope of Belgian economic dependence rules.

Want to know more?

  • Read the full Rechtskundig Weekblad article by Benjamin Magnus (Dutch) here.

  • Read the full text of the Court of Cassation judgment (French) here.

For questions about economic dependence or dispute resolution, please contact Benjamin Magnus or your usual contact at contrast.


Related insights

View all insights

In for more news?

Why sign up for our newsletter? Because we keep things clear – without any heavy legal jargon. ‘In the Picture’ delivers concise updates on legal developments and practical insights that you can actually use.

One newsletter per month, in English, French and Dutch.

Sign up
close

Log into your account

close

Forgot password?

Request a new password by providing your email address.

close

Password reset

Enter your new password.

close

Password registration

close

Activate your account

Activate your account by providing your email address.

close

Thanks

You will receive an email with a link to enter a new password.

Close
close

Thanks

Your new password is successfully saved.

Close